Jocelyn and Wesley Earnest: A Fresh Start Cut Short

In December 2007, 38-year-old Jocelyn Earnest was finally finding her footing after a painful and drawn-out separation. The former West Virginia University standout basketball player was living in Forest, Virginia, and had just accepted an exciting corporate promotion with a six-figure salary. With the holiday season arriving, she was busy making plans to bake cookies with her friends and visit her family in West Virginia. She was nearly through a dark chapter of her life, eagerly looking forward to a bright and independent future.

That future was abruptly stolen on the morning of December 20th. Concerned after being unable to reach her, Jocelyn’s close friend Marcy Shepherd used a spare key to enter the home. Inside, she was hit by a heavy wave of heat and discovered Jocelyn lying motionless on the living room floor, surrounded by a pool of blood with a revolver and a typed suicide note nearby. On the surface, it had the initial appearance of a tragic suicide, but investigators quickly realized that almost nothing about the scene held up to scrutiny.

The home's thermostat had been cranked all the way up to 90 degrees, an apparent attempt by the killer to manipulate the core body temperature and mask the exact time of death. Jocelyn’s beloved dog was found trapped in his crate, heavily panting from the suffocating heat. Furthermore, a forensic examination revealed gravity-defying blood patterns on Jocelyn’s face and pinned strands of hair, proving her body had been roughly dragged and re-positioned after she was shot. Suspicion immediately locked onto her estranged husband, Wesley Earnest—a high school assistant principal drowning in over a million dollars of debt, driven heavily by his obsession with building an aggressive luxury lake house. What followed was a dramatic, multi-year legal battle involving a suspicious house fire, an overturned first trial, and a shocking courtroom admission that left everyone stunned.

Case Timeline

The Evidence Locker

• The Gravity-Defying Crime Scene: Jocelyn was found fully dressed in her winter coat, but dried blood patterns flowing "uphill" across her cheek and pinned strands of hair under her head proved her body was moved and straightened post-mortem.

• The Thermostat Tactics: The killer cranked the home's thermostat to its maximum setting of 90 degrees, leaving Jocelyn's dog panting heavily down the hall, in a clear attempt to accelerate decomposition and disrupt forensic timeline calculations.

• The Fingerprinted Suicide Note: While the generic, unsigned suicide note was typed, advanced chemical testing using ninhydrin exposed two latent fingerprints that matched Wesley Earnest.

• The Borrowed Vehicle and Swapped Tires: Wesley drove a borrowed Chevy Silverado on the night of the murder. Weeks later, he used an alias to pay cash at a tire shop to replace the truck's pristine, high-end tires with cheap Dunlops to cover up any potential matching track evidence.

• The Arrogant Admission: On the witness stand during the second trial, Wesley walked directly into a prosecutor's trap. When confronted with forged entries on a butcher-block timeline Jocelyn kept for therapy, Wesley smirked and admitted to the jury that he broke into her house through an unlocked window.

• The Unidentified Male DNA: Drops of dried male blood and stray hairs found in Jocelyn's guest bathroom did not match Wesley or any of the 25 individuals tracked in the case, leaving a lingering question mark for the defense to exploit.

Tina & Rich’s Takeaways

"It's just so shocking to me. Someone who is obviously very arrogant, very confident in his abilities to win over this jury would make a blunder... I also have no doubt that Wesley is guilty." — Rich

"This makes me really sad that Jocelyn gave up a lot of what she wanted out of life for Wesley. Like she really wanted kids and she gave that up. She loved holidays and she gave up having a close family celebration at the holiday season." — Tina

Sources and Further Reading

• Fanning, Diane. Under Cover of the Night: A True Story of Sex, Greed, and Murder. Berkley Books, Penguin Group, 2014.

• CBS News: "83 words and 20 questions: The mysterious suicide note in the Jocelyn Branham Earnest case."

• CBS News: "Murder or suicide: How did Jocelyn Earnest die?"

• Supreme Court of the United States: Wesley Brian Earnest Petition for Writ of Certiorari (2021)

• InsuranceNewsNet: "Earnest trial focuses on frame of mind"

What do you think?

This case leaves us with so many questions, and we want to hear your thoughts:

1. Do you agree with the ultimate verdict? Is there any realistic scenario in your mind where a third party was involved, or does the mountain of circumstantial evidence put it completely to rest?

2. Does the unidentified male DNA found in the guest bathroom give you pause, or do you think it was completely unrelated to the crime scene?

3. Wesley chose to take the witness stand in both of his murder trials. Do you think his extreme narcissism is what ultimately sealed his fate when he boasted about breaking into her home?

Head over to our Contact Page to drop us an email, or share your voice directly with us on our Voicemail Page (and hey, don't forget to submit your funniest entry for our joke contest!). If you want to support the show and gain access to early, ad-free episodes and monthly bonus features, join our family on Patreon!