Love Marry Kill

A happily married couple discusses true crimes involving not-so-happily married couples.Support the show: patreon.com/LoveMarryKill

Recent Blog Posts

The Pelley Family Murders (Part 2)
June 1, 2026

The Pelley Family Murders (Part 2)

The grief that fractured two families in coastal Florida didn't vanish when they relocated to rural Indiana. Instead, it simmered under the roof of the Olive Branch church parsonage until April 29, 1989—the night a long-awaited Senior Prom col…

Read the Blog Post
The Pelley Family Murders (Part 1)
May 25, 2026

The Pelley Family Murders (Part 1)

On a picture-perfect spring morning in 1989, the tight-knit congregation of Olive Branch United Brethren Church filtered into their rural Indiana parking lot, expecting a standard Sunday service. But the morning was unnervingly quiet. The church doo…

Read the Blog Post
Michele and Martin MacNeill (Part 2)
May 23, 2026

Michele and Martin MacNeill (Part 2)

When we left off in Part 1, Michele MacNeill had reluctantly agreed to a massive, multi-procedure facelift at the aggressive urging of her husband, Martin. Despite warnings from her primary care physician about her dangerously high blood pressure , …

Read the Blog Post

Reviews

Nicest couple in the murder business 😍
You two are so stinking corny and lovely… your wholesomeness is unmatched and honestly pray my kiddos someday have a marriage like you two🙌 getting two kids through higher education right now, but someday I hope to financially support you.
The perfect listen!
This is a great podcast for true crime fans! Tina and Rich present interesting cases with sensitivity and respect. They are the perfect length and well presented. Their banter is funny but doesn’t overwhelm the case.
My favorite podcast
I look forward to every episode. It’s like listening to 2 friends. Rich and Tina are both so great at telling the story while honoring the victims in each episode. I also look forward to the Mother’s Day episode every year now. Tina and Emma do a great job!
True Crime Done Right
Cubs‼️Chicago-born, Miami-raised superfan here 🌴😂 — I came for the true crime, stayed for the married chaos, and now every episode has me investigating couples like I qualify for detective benefits. Rich & Tina have created one of the Greatest true crime out there‼️Fully obsessed with Love, Marry, Kill- please let out those tears Tina, I’d venture to say most appreciate your emotion! Always enjoy Emma! She is excellent.Lulu
Love them
As a mom to 12 kids, my days can be quite hectic! I love When the kids are in school and I get to listen to your podcast while cleaning the house. It just makes me laugh. I love the back-and-forth. And I love your little comments about snack.I do wish you guys would post the recipes or links to buy the snacks on your Instagram, but thanks for making my day just a little bit better. Keep up the hard work
Love Marry Kill Podcast
I started with hosts Tina and Rich when they first came online. I am a true-crime nut and I am entertained by spousal murders, mainly bc it continues to surprised me how dumb one spouse is when they kill their spouse. Also, I will never understand how a spouse can take a loving parent away from their kids. Tina and Rich do not disappoint. Sometimes I am already familiar with a case, but love their take on it. Tina often says "Can you believe that? " I am thinking "yup". They are an engaging cou
Murder with Snacks!
I came across this podcast while looking for something new. I am fascinated with true crime and who doesn’t enjoy a good snack? Now you can have both. Tina and Rich are so warm and engaging, they tell the true crime story well and start off with the snack of the day. I’ve already got some new recipes to try. I’m so glad to have found my new favorite podcast! Thank you Tina and Rich-love you both!
Send a Voicemail