True crime tales of love gone wrong

Love Marry Kill

In 'Love Marry Kill,' a happily married couple delves into chilling true crime cases involving couples who faced deadly outcomes. Each episode reveals the heart-wrenching stories behind the headlines, making listeners question just how well we know those we love.

Recent Episodes

Aug. 31, 2026

Kristil and Dan Krug

In 2023, when Kristil Krug began receiving harassing messages from an apparent stalker, her world was turned upside down. As the messages became more threatening and personal, she went to police for help, but tracking down her stalker proved challenging. On December 14 Kristil’s husband, Dan, contacted police to perform a welfare check at their home when he couldn’t reach her. Kristil’s worst fears had come true, but the person who had been terrorizing her was much closer to home than anyone rea
Aug. 24, 2026

Simeonette Mapes and Jonathan Crupi

On the afternoon of July 5th, 2012, New Springville schoolteacher Simeonette Mapes-Crupi was found stabbed to death inside her own Staten Island home, just two days before what would have been her fifth wedding anniversary. Her husband, fellow teacher Jonathan Crupi, told police he'd come home to find the house ransacked. On the surface, it looked like a burglary gone wrong, but the deeper investigators looked, the more the "robbery" theory started to fall apart. What followed was a years-long i
Aug. 17, 2026

Betty and Allan Gore/Candy and Pat Montgomery - Part 3 of 3

In 1980, Betty and Allan Gore and Candy and Pat Montgomery seemed to have much in common. They were raising young families, active in the same small Methodist church, and navigating the pressures of marriage, careers, and parenthood in the growing suburbs north of Dallas. This three-part series follows the relationships that developed between the two couples, the affair that changed all of their lives, and the investigation and trial that became one of the most talked-about murder cases in Texas
Aug. 10, 2026

Betty and Allan Gore/Candy and Pat Montgomery - Part 2 of 3

In 1980, Betty and Allan Gore and Candy and Pat Montgomery seemed to have much in common. They were raising young families, active in the same small Methodist church, and navigating the pressures of marriage, careers, and parenthood in the growing suburbs north of Dallas. This three-part series follows the relationships that developed between the two couples, the affair that changed all of their lives, and the investigation and trial that became one of the most talked-about murder cases in Texas
Aug. 3, 2026

Betty and Allan Gore/Candy and Pat Montgomery - Part 1 of 3

In 1980, Betty and Allan Gore and Candy and Pat Montgomery seemed to have much in common. They were raising young families, active in the same small Methodist church, and navigating the pressures of marriage, careers, and parenthood in the growing suburbs north of Dallas. This three-part series follows the relationships that developed between the two couples, the affair that changed all of their lives, and the investigation and trial that became one of the most talked-about murder cases in Texas
July 27, 2026

Maya and Larry Millete

When 39-year-old mother of three Maya Millete walked up to her Chula Vista home carrying grocery bags on the afternoon of January 7, 2021, security cameras captured what looked like a routine Thursday. But by the next morning, the vibrant Navy contract specialist had vanished without a trace, leaving behind a new Jeep Wrangler, plans for a family road trip, and an appointment with a divorce attorney scheduled for that very week. What followed was a years-long investigation that peeled back the

Recent Blog Posts

Aug. 31, 2026

The Ax Murder of Betty Gore: Suburban Secrets, Church Choir Affairs, and the Trial of Candy Montgomery

Note: This article contains spoilers. Listen to the Love Marry Kill series on Betty Gore and Candy Montgomery here. Overview On the scorching morning of Friday, June 13, 1980, life in Collin County, Texas, revolved around the close-knit commun…
Aug. 31, 2026

The Stalking of Kristil Krug: Digital Deception, a Framed Ex, and Murder in the Garage

Note: This article contains spoilers. Listen to the Love Marry Kill episode here. On the morning of December 14, 2023, 43-year-old Kristil Krug went through the routine chaos of getting her three children ready and off to school from their quiet…
July 27, 2026

The Vanishing of Maya Millete: A Trail of Digital Control, Spells, and the Desert

Note: This article contains spoilers. Listen to the Love Marry Kill episode here.  On the afternoon of Thursday, January 7, 2021, a home surveillance camera in Chula Vista, California, recorded 39-year-old Maya Millete walking up her driveway carry…

Reviews

Review
Love the podcast, even on stories I had heard before you always add interesting facts I did not know.
Catching up
I came to this podcast recently based on Reddit comment and I have been catching up on the back catalogue ever since. I find myself drawn in to the stories and their focused and empathetic telling.
Nicest couple in the murder business 😍
You two are so stinking corny and lovely… your wholesomeness is unmatched and honestly pray my kiddos someday have a marriage like you two🙌 getting two kids through higher education right now, but someday I hope to financially support you.
The perfect listen!
This is a great podcast for true crime fans! Tina and Rich present interesting cases with sensitivity and respect. They are the perfect length and well presented. Their banter is funny but doesn’t overwhelm the case.
My favorite podcast
I look forward to every episode. It’s like listening to 2 friends. Rich and Tina are both so great at telling the story while honoring the victims in each episode. I also look forward to the Mother’s Day episode every year now. Tina and Emma do a great job!
True Crime Done Right
Cubs‼️Chicago-born, Miami-raised superfan here 🌴😂 — I came for the true crime, stayed for the married chaos, and now every episode has me investigating couples like I qualify for detective benefits. Rich & Tina have created one of the Greatest true crime out there‼️Fully obsessed with Love, Marry, Kill- please let out those tears Tina, I’d venture to say most appreciate your emotion! Always enjoy Emma! She is excellent. Lulu
Just the best.
I've been listening for quite a while. I'm never bored. I love the banter. It feels genuine and well thought out, and researched. Their marriage is goals . Something else I love, is that there is no political leaning at all. Nowadays, it sneaks in everywhere and leaves people feeling alienated. Despite the podcasters having opposite political opinions than I do (I only know this from social media), I never feel unwelcome listening. I just love them. Thank you for being kind, warm and welcoming,
Love them
As a mom to 12 kids, my days can be quite hectic! I love When the kids are in school and I get to listen to your podcast while cleaning the house. It just makes me laugh. I love the back-and-forth. And I love your little comments about snack. I do wish you guys would post the recipes or links to buy the snacks on your Instagram, but thanks for making my day just a little bit better. Keep up the hard work
LMK quickly became a favorite
Love the banter, the snacks, and your compassionate perspectives on the crimes. Your research is top tier. Your episodes on the Menendez brothers changed everything I thought I knew about the family and the crime.
Love Marry Kill Podcast
I started with hosts Tina and Rich when they first came online. I am a true-crime nut and I am entertained by spousal murders, mainly bc it continues to surprised me how dumb one spouse is when they kill their spouse. Also, I will never understand how a spouse can take a loving parent away from their kids. Tina and Rich do not disappoint. Sometimes I am already familiar with a case, but love their take on it. Tina often says "Can you believe that? " I am thinking "yup". They are an engaging cou
Murder with Snacks!
I came across this podcast while looking for something new. I am fascinated with true crime and who doesn’t enjoy a good snack? Now you can have both. Tina and Rich are so warm and engaging, they tell the true crime story well and start off with the snack of the day. I’ve already got some new recipes to try. I’m so glad to have found my new favorite podcast! Thank you Tina and Rich-love you both!
Favorite True Crime Podcast
I’ve listened to every episode. It’s THAT good. Great cases, good perspectives, well researched. But what sets this podcast apart is Rich & Tina. They are both so lovely and their relationship is just beautiful. Two really great humans who make a really great partnership! I just need to figure out if I can send them a snack sometime!
Love you guys!
I’m a long time listener since the beginning and I love seeing LMK pop up in my feed when new episodes come out! Keep up the great work guys!
I LOVE THIS PODCAST
I have been a “ day one” listener! Love Love this couple! I was even writing to Tina periodically in the beginning but, they are WAY too popular now and she is probably too busy to answer back to me lol so I don’t want to waste her time! I love this couple, I still listen avidly and will never stop!!! I feel like they are my friends( not in a creepy way). I hope they never stop!!! Cindy from Warrenton VA 💜
Best true crime podcast ever!!!
I am crazy about Rich and Tina! They are just the best. They do a thoughtful and thorough investigation into each case, highlighting the victims and they bring it to the podcast with seriousness speckled with humor, love, and snacks. I have tried to listen to other podcasts and they seem to mostly fall short when held up to the LMK standard. I highly recommend...really better than 5 stars!
Story telling
I absolutely love listening to you both, I’ve said it before, it is like I’m hearing a story from friends. As a teacher it’s like adult storytelling.
So Entertaining!
My husband and I love your podcast. We love your style! Very entertaining and interesting. We look forward to listening each week! Thanks!
My Favorite True Crime Podcast!
I usually don’t care for banter.. but the two hosts are SO engaging and on point, that I enjoy it here! There are many podcasters… but sadly, very few who combine the virtues of very good storytelling, thorough research.. and good voices. (There are podcasts out there that have okay content.. but the narrators’ voices are simply appalling.) Do give “LMK” a listen.. I guarantee you will be as addicted as I am. Literate, smart and witty.. what’s not to love?
Simple & sweet
I love true crime & had been looking for another podcast, this is the one! Tina & Rich are sweet & keep it simple: straight to the facts while maintaining great storytelling format. Absolutely love their research, banter & thoughts; even if they are cat people!
Tru3-Crim3-lov3r
Tina & Rich I love you guys so much you are the ones getting me through this boring summer. Every day I’m on the edge of my seat waiting for the next episode to come out . Snacks and murder mystery’s and romance are 3 of my favorite things. I love the way you put together fun family life and shocking stories . Keep doing what your doing! Snack recommendation: Kodiak cake mix protein bites P.S the amount of shows that take place were I live is insane!!!
Good choice!
Tina and Rich are very engaging and fun. They are good storytellers and always respectful to the subject and people involved. Highly recommend!
Murder, snacks, Costco, toasters, Michigan weather, lions, tigers, bears, and so much more! Oh, my!
For years, I’ve listened to so many true crime podcasts. I recently randomly discovered Love Marry Kill, and it quickly became my favorite. I love the amount of research, detail. and care that Tina and Rich put into every single episode. I don’t always love banter in other podcasts, but with LMK, Tina and Rich draw me in every time. They are relatable, heartwarming, humble, and absolutely delightful. I am looking forward to sending them snacks and magnets from Idaho!
Knowledgeable
Thank you for making this podcast and sharing your research with us! Very informative. I came across this podcast after listening to a few episodes of Murder in Illinois and I was so disheartened by the lack of information it shared.
Great Podcast
I look forward every week for Rich and Tina to bring out a new story for their podcast. Their information on the crimes that they research and relay are very thorough and informative. I love their banter before and after their stories and I just love their voices as they are so easy to listen to. I recommend this podcast to listeners as it is my favourite out of all the crime podcasts. Do yourself a favour and listen to Love Marry Kill.
Awesome!! Very well done.
I heard about this podcast through a Reddit forum and had to at least give one episode a try so I could leave an informed review. I’m not even a huge true crime fan, but this podcast it so well done. I went back to the Jennifer and Sarah Hart episode and was astounded. Couldn’t even finish. 😵‍💫 This podcast is so well done and these two know what they’re doing! So glad I came across it.
Fantastic
This is my favorite podcast. I’m a true crime junkie and the research and presentation of the cases is phenomenal! Rich and Tina deliver with compassion and empathy. I think it’s nice that they also give numbers and websites people can use if they are in a similar situation. They also stay neutral and they do not bash law enforcement. Love you guys!!! Keep up the good work!!!!
Send a Voicemail