Listener Reviews

Top favorite

I listen to so many true crime podcasts and this one is truly top tier. Yall are great!

I stumbled upon this podcast because I had basically run out of true crime stories to listen to. I have listened to most of the Big podcasts available. This one is in my top favorites! They are funny, relatable, not too much banter and best of all, they show a real respect and care for the victims in these tragedies. A lot of times podcasts will forget that these are real people with real families, but Tina and Rich are so empathetic and understanding to that and handle each case with such care. They are awesome!

I love and big time goals. Three marriages later and I’m single, I wanna be like you!

This is one of the better true crime podcasts out there. Interesting cases, some of them quite obscure which makes for a good change of pace. The hosts definitely do their research and have a great vibe between them.The only drawback/criticism that I have is that the “treats” intro and the post case discussion are both beyond tiresome. Both segments are so unnecessary and irritating. I fast forward through both every time. It basically just adds a completely useless 15-20 minutes to every episode.Still, overall a very good true crime podcast.

I hope I can find a relationship like Tina & Rich’s one day. They are the cutest. They are so through with their stories and are great reporters of each story.

Such kind hosts delivering such horrid crime! Love these 2.

I listen to several true crime podcasts, and this is definitely one of my favorites!! I enjoy the way the stories are told, the questions that they ask each other (which a lot of times is the question I’m thinking), and the true respect shown for the victims. I love the banter and especially love snack time!

I came back to edit my prior review after listening for a few months. They have grown on me and while on occasion I do think they show too much sympathy to perpetrators, overall they do a good job.

I have been listening to you guys for a really long time,Tina and Rich I enjoy your conversations. I love everything about your podcast. I don’t know why I’ve never submitted a review before but better late than never. ❤️

I rave about you to pretty much anyone who lets me talk about murder, pretty much forgetting appropriate social skills in favor of just assuming my audience (the room) has been read appropriately.Rich and Tina, look how many stars I’ve tossed up in your favor, just today! Your show is so well researched, written and executed. It’s obvious you two correctly chose your niche without even getting to read all the rooms and then proceed to grasp the perfect amount of compassion, sensitivity, and tell your stories, and you know we will react!! We have no doubt that you will leave us with a new perspective of our perceived security, our sense of belonging and especially what we can do as individuals to show how far we will go to step out to protect our home base. You guys know I love you and LMK (but can we please vote again to “enhance” the pod’s vibes by abandoning the most cringy theme song ever). But I have no suggestions except I have implicit faith that Rich, you will lead us on with the research and writing and production… but hecka most importantly is your ability to have us step right in with you and Tina….But Tina? If I’m still in the running…. Do you think Rich will let you step out for a sec to mail to me some Brown butter chocolate chip cookies? And I will always and forever rate and review you with joy, and not just because of the promise of hand delivery from the Cookie Temptress?Love you and your sweet little family

From someone who has listened to true crime since the dawn of time (it seems) this show would hands down win the award for most improved if there was such a thing. I could not get through one of the first episodes because of the constant interruptions. (nothing personal; it bothers me when ANYone does that) and vowed to never listen again. Fast forward to over a year later and I found they were covering a case I really wanted to hear. So I gritted my teeth and decided to push through it😅. I was STUNNED to hear how much it had changed for the better!! Truly a completely different show!! Now easily one of my top 5 favs.

You both are so sweet!!! Sorry we (Chiefs) beat you!

Their banter makes me laugh, thank you. Great research and respectful story telling.

Rich and Tina are wonderful podcasters, a sweet, married couple, and they feel like they are my great friends! I love the way they tell the cases, I love their banter and especially their snack time. I'm a baker and I look forward to hearing what they are having for a snack. Give them a listen.

Most episodes are really good. ButDON’T start from the beginning; the wife is uber annoying and interrupts her husband all the time. I tried a few and couldn’t get through them because of her. She is better in ones starting in 2024. (She still makes awkward comments at times-but doesn’t interrupt inappropriately & go on &on. ) However, they both research the cases really well and go in depth on ones that you may have heard of.

New listener and love this show. Love the banter between this married couple. Love the snack break. Very impressed with the research put into each episode. Love each show I’ve listened to so far!!

This pod was a great find, I really appreciate the way the hosts don’t sensationalize the stories. They honor the victims while also creating an entertaining true crime show. Keep up the good work!

Nothing beats you two, the banter, and the way you tell each case is second to none. My favorite true crime podcast!

One of my favorite podcasts. Tina and Rich talk with empathy and compassion, and go over each case with well researched details. I thoroughly enjoy listening to them and collecting all the snack recipes! I love the snack part of their podcast!

One of my favorite true crime podcasts - I love the storytelling and the fun relationship- don’t listen to the haters about the snacks - who doesn’t love snacks? I think there is the perfect balance of talk and facts ! Keep up the the great storytelling

I’m so glad that I discovered this podcast. The podcasters are real people who do the research and writing. The couple doesn’t have exaggerated personas. Tina and Rich are authentic in their empathy and it really comes across. Every time Tina tears up so do I. They don’t have a media conglomerate backing them and it shows in a good way <3 Please don’t change! I feel like I’m listening to my neighbors as we sit around the living room. I love the little glimpses into their lives that bookend the episodes and I can’t forget the snacks! This podcast along with “Casefile” and “The Consult” are my faves

Just found you and you are my new favorite! Am I too late for a cookie?

Hands down the best! Tina and Rich, you two are fantastic storytellers. The details that you put into each podcast, you can tell you love what you do and your research really shines through. Btw, the banter is great.