Listener Reviews

I’ve been listening for over a year now and enjoy the format. Tina and Rich banter back and forth but it’s fun and respectful. I’m not opposed to colorful language but I like that they keep it clean as it makes it easier to listen at work or around young ears. They get to the point without disparaging remarks about the people involved or crass jokes. I like that they can deliver the information and not let their emotions hijack the narrative. They show the right amount of sympathy and emotion. I also like the snacks and the conversation at the beginning.

It’s a great mix of respect, information and comedy!

I love everything about this podcast. I really enjoy the snack segment and Rich and Tina’s banter back and forth. All episodes are very well researched and hold my attention throughout. I’m really picky about listening to some voices on other podcasts, but both voices of the hosts are smooth and soothing. I have never payed for Patreon additions of any podcast with the exception of Love, Marry, Kill.

Not too much small talk. Nice telling of the story and the details - really enjoy the show.

I just recently found this podcast and I love it! They do such a great job and also give you info you don’t hear in every other podcast. I’m going back to the beginning and playing all there old ones! Great job Tina and Rich!

I found the podcast by running out of shows on my other various known true crime regular favorites. Not knowing anything about the pod, or who Rich and Tina were, I skipped the first and last portions and formerly was like just get me to the case! I’ve since grown to love their chatting and banter, they are great together discussing this interesting niche of true crime. Tina you have some seriously good one liners that make me lol. Keep up the great work!

I found these two when I first started down a rabbit hole following a case I was interested in and I’ve been hooked ever since! I’m currently making my way through their whole listing of podcasts and I’m really loving their take on things and learning about cases I hadn’t heard about before. The dynamic between Tina and Rich is really fun as well. Highly recommend!

Very interesting. Keep up the great work!

I really enjoy this show. Tina and Rich’s voices are so calming and relaxing. My only feedback is I prefer the cases where children are not mentioned. I understand that can be a part of murder/ domestic situations, but it’s so hard to digest. On the flip side, I really like the newly married/ newly engaged episodes. Otherwise, I listen to their episodes over and over!

I love your show SO much! I know it’s a true crime podcast, but I appreciate your humor, love your banter, and of course love that you are always respectful of victims. Definitely my favorite show - and I’ve been listening to podcasts for a long time! Keep the episodes coming.

Tina and Rich are my favorite to listen too. I listen daily at work for 6 hours , and I swear I’m laughing, and crying all day. They give very good factual information about the crimes they cover, and also have great off topic chatter as well. A show with a great vibe and dynamic. I love the snack time too. I just listened to the birthday where Tina wanted reviews for presents but didn’t want to ask so Rich did, so funny. I forget what month it was but I’m just listening to all older ones :) Happy Birthday, Tina!

I usually don’t care for banter.. but the two hosts are SO engaging and on point, that I enjoy it here! There are many podcasters… but sadly, very few who combine the virtues of very good storytelling, thorough research.. and good voices. (There are podcasts out there that have okay content.. but the narrators’ voices are simply appalling.) Do give “LMK” a listen.. I guarantee you will be as addicted as I am. Literate, smart and witty.. what’s not to love?

They are awesome to listen to and have great voices. I am very picky about podcasts I listen to but when I came across theirs, I was hooked after episode 1. I love the stories, how passionate and caring they are and how they share about themselves as well. It’s nice getting to know them.

Despite making me question humanity every morning as I start my day, I just love this show. The hosts are genuine and strive to be objective. They’re also very intentional in their respect and honor of the victims and their families. They seem like people I would love to have as my neighbors. Engaging, well-researched and told with compassion, I can’t rate it highly enough.

Found this podcast about a month ago and I’ve already listened to every episode. I really like the storytelling and the little banter between you guys. Keep up the great work!!

I used to skip over the snack banter, but as I’ve gotten to the more recent episodes I find that I’m listening to the whole episode. I like the newer format of both reading. Great production value (I don’t notice the mouth sounds like I used to. Not sure if they’ve changed something or I just stopped noticing it). This podcast is now in my regular rotation and I really look forward to new episodes. Keep up the great work!

Tina! Do not pay attention to negative reviews. You are funny and engaging. Rich, you do such a great job with production. My only complaint…you ONLY put out one episode a week. PS. I love your snacks!

Tina and Rich do a fantastic job of researching and presenting these cases. Bravo!! My fav podcast. I listen to it religiously.

Love the format of your show. You both are terrific and truly compliment each other. Thanks for taking the time to research and share these stories.

LMK is one of my favorite, go-to podcasts. Their research is thorough, and they explain the cases very well. I appreciate that they aren’t political (as too many are) and that there’s a level of humor and levity, as I find pods without that are too dry or too sad and can ruin your day. Their balance is excellent, they are a great team. I especially love Tina’s quick whit and comments, and I love Rich’s sense of humor and support of his wife. They’re a great podcast duo and I look forward to every episode! I’d love to see them collaborate with other podcasts to see how they would do, I think that could be fun! Xoxo Allie

I think Rich and Tina do a great job discussing difficult stories clearly and with compassion. I love their friendly banter which lightens it up a little while still respectful of the serious dialogue. I also appreciate that they don’t mention any political views!!

I really love listening to you both- how you tell the stories, interact with each other and talking about your snacks 🤓 love it all! This is the one I go to first on my podcast list! Thank you ☺️

I really appreciate the way this couple lays out the information. I love that it’s not sensationalized or grow task but at the same time it gives enough detail to paint a picture of what is happening in each situation. Rich does such a great job of building his wife up and he always has an encouraging word but I gave this show four stars because Tina is very condescending towards her husband. I tried to ignore it, but she does it a lot. For instance, in the latest episode Rich says to his wife, do you want to explain what levity is and she does the snarky laugh that she often does with her husband and says well I think everybody already knows what that is but…. And she gives this brief description. No Tina, not everybody does know what that is so you shouldn’t assume. He’s just doing his job of being thorough and you should support him and not laugh at him. Seriously this happens a lot and I feel really bad for the husband because he just seems like a really cool guy and he does a great job connecting with the listener. If it wasn’t for him, I probably wouldn’t listen at all because she bothers me that much. When it comes to this attitude.

Only giving 5 stars for Rich. Tina is very condescending to her husband. She constantly interrupts him and takes his lightheaded jokes way too seriously, however Rich seems very kind and enjoyable and that’s why I will continue to listen.