Listener Reviews

Such a great show!

Ok, I've heard many of these true crime stories before, BUT these two give tiny extra details that I haven't heard anywhere else! Plus, they're just so darn cute and charming to listen to

I found this podcast a couple months ago and started from episode one and have binged every single episode. I just love the hosts. I loved the “Peterson Project” I enjoy all the episodes but have really enjoyed when they both research the same episode. I have to laugh about the snacks portion of the show especially the time Rich bought like four gas station snacks (one being carrots) and Tina made a comment about how she knew which gas station he’d gone to and he really could have chosen better selections. 🤣I am always looking for a good snack to surprise my husband with so keep the suggestions coming. Thank you for being respectful to the victims and their families and I look forward to each new episode.

I found this podcast on accident and have grown to really love it! Tina and Rich are adorable and it’s sweet to hear a couple enjoying their hobby together especially in contrast to the clearly dysfunctional relationships at the center of the stories. I enjoy their episodes on some of the lesser known cases the most. Keep it up!

I recently found this podcast and once I realized I live in the area made me want to listen to it to support. Though I’ve listened to many other true crime podcasts, many on the same person/topic, I still will listen to the episodes as there is always a different take/observation that I appreciate. Keep it up!

I started listening to Tina and Rich when I stumbled upon a blog about Michigan podcasting. I have become a huge fan due to Rich’s great analysis and Tina’s genuine care for every case they cover. They are an amazing team, down to earth, and great storytellers. There are a lot of true crime podcast duos out there, but no one hooks me in like these two!

I love their down-to-Earth perspectives on the stories they cover as well as finding out what they’ll be snacking on during the episodes! Great job, Tina & Rich, I am hooked!

Tina and Rich are so thoughtful to the stories they are telling and put an emphasis on the victims. They are also fun and informative. One of my favorites to listen to!

Love you both. You make listening a pleasure. You bring the victims to life with your care and concern. They are not just news but people we can feel the loss of and sorrow for their families. You are by far the best pod cast I have listened too!

I like the conversation between this pair.

The hosts are lovely. They work well together and research each case with different types of personal takes. Each host is smart. Five very deserving stars.

Happy birthday week to Tina! I also love the theme music, BTW😁The research is deep and I love the Michigan accents.

I wait all week for new episodes to come out. I always love listening to Rich and Tina’s voice because I am from the Midwest (Southside Chicago) and I live in Florida now. Hearing that Midwest accent just makes my heart happy. I love how caring and how much work that Rich and Tina put into each episode to make sure they represent the victim and their families properly. Happy birthday Tina and keep up the great episodes. Jaclyn

I’m so happy that I found this podcast, and even happier to support via patreon. You both approach each episode with empathy and compassion towards the victims. I also love the snack break and anecdotal stories about your own relationship. My only complaint is that there are not more episodes to binge. Thank you for all you do!

Rich and Tina thoughtfully research and report true crime in such an easy way to digest. They always have and rate a snack and have just an overall wholesome show. I love that they show real emotion for the victims too. Hearing about unhealthy couples from a healthy couple is a refreshing take on the genre. Highly recommend!

How do these two manage to make murder stories “easy listening?!” Love having them playing in the background while I work or do chores. Both are articulate, calm, & have impressive vocabularies!

You two are just so good—professional but relatable, quietly opinionated but objective. Your research is stellar, your empathy for victims is spot on, and I love that you are not covering cases that everyone else has already covered. Great job. Five stars!

I found this podcast by scrolling through the recommendations and I’ve been religiously listening for over a year. I love them. I feel like they do such a good job with research and it feels like listening to your friends tell you a story. They’re my new favorite podcast and I recommend it to friends all the time. I’ve been looking for a way to give back and this review will have to do. Thank you for getting me through boring work days 🫶🏽

I find myself going back to re-listen to previous episodes because I enjoy your show so much. Your demeanor , your candor, and your back and forth is just so enjoyable to be able to experience on the podcast. Thank you for sharing your time with us!

I love your podcast!! No matter what kind of day, you two put a smile on my face. The podcasts are superb. Keep up the great work!!

So glad to have found your podcast, as it is now one of my favorites.

Love listening to you both!

I just found this podcast. Love how real it feels, and how you two interact! Great stories, I could listen all day. Something about a good married couple(from a divorced woman😂) just sets my soul on fire. I love how in almost every episode you throw in a story of you of your lives relevant to the story you’re telling, how you describe the setting, and all the background info you provide! Not to mention the snacks!!! Keep doing a great job, you have a new obsessed fan ❤️

The only thing I don’t like is that I’m all caught up! 😔 Now have wait weekly. Thank you for your realness. Your research is great. Your banter is genuine. Your snacks are fun. And your love is adorable. It’s a great balance of sharing these terrible stories in honorable ways and sharing your own process, perspectives, and personalities.