Episodes

Brenda Schaefer, a beautiful 36 year old from Louisville Kentucky, went missing in September of 1988. Her car was found abandoned and vandalized early on a Sunday morning, but Brenda was nowhere to be found. Mel Ignatow, Brenda’s one-time fiancé, was an immediate suspect, but there was no direct evidence implicating him and no body. In part two of this two-part episode, we discuss Mel's trial and the aftermath. Sources: Double Jeopardy, book by Bob Hill from 1995 Dark Heart, Iron Hand - Gettin...

Artificial Intelligence is advancing at an amazing rate. In this special bonus episode, we take a step back from our usual true crime stories to discuss AI as it relates to the world of crime. How is AI helping law enforcement? How is it helping criminals? What new forms of crime are we likely to see enabled by AI? And what is the existential threat posed by AI to humanity and what efforts are underway to avoid catastrophe? Sources: https://www.npr.org/2023/01/25/1151435033/a-robot-was-schedule...

Brenda Schaefer, a beautiful 36 year old from Louisville Kentucky, went missing in September of 1988. Her car was found abandoned and vandalized early on a Sunday morning, but Brenda was nowhere to be found. Mel Ignatow, Brenda’s one-time fiancé, was an immediate suspect, but there was no direct evidence implicating him and no body. In part one of this two-part episode, we discuss Brenda’s background, Brenda and Mel’s relationship, and the investigation into her disappearance. Sources: Double J...

In part two of this two part episode, Tina tells the story of Susan Bolling and Felix Polk, who first met when she was 15 and he was 39. In this episode we talk about what led to Felix’s murder and the crazy trial where Susan defended herself. Will Susan be able to convince the jury the murder was self defense? We also discuss the murder of Pamela Vitale and the connection to Ed Gein.

In part one of this two part episode, Tina tells the story of Susan Bolling and Felix Polk, who first met when she was 15 and he was 39. Felix was Susan’s psychotherapist who took advantage of his position and began an inappropriate sexual relationship with her. They later married and had 3 sons together before Felix was murdered by Susan in 2002. Was it self defense or cold blooded murder? Listen to this disturbing tale of psychotherapy gone wrong and intense grooming. We also discuss the satan...

Barry and Honey Sherman, a wealthy and philanthropic couple, were killed in December of 2017 at their home in Toronto. The circumstances of their death were bizarre and mysterious. Barry and Honey were loved by a lot of people, but they also had enemies who hated them both. In part two of this two-part episode, we discuss the suspects, possible motives, and the legacy of Barry and Honey Sherman.

In this bonus episode, we summarize several cases in the news, including the killing of six people in Oklahoma by convicted sex offender Jesse McFadden, the murder of Dr. Devon Hoover in Detroit, and the parole hearing of Leo Schofield.

Barry and Honey Sherman, an incredibly wealthy and philanthropic couple, were killed in December of 2017 at their home in Toronto. The circumstances of their death were bizarre and mysterious. Barry and Honey were loved by a lot of people, but they also had enemies who hated them both. In part one of this two-part episode, we share Barry’s and Honey’s background, the crime scene, and the beginnings of the investigation.

This week we go back in time to 1892 in Fall River Massachusetts and try to solve the most famous unsolved crime in American history, the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden. Did Lizzie Borden kill her parents in cold blood to gain access to the family fortune or was she an innocent Sunday school teacher and the real murderer evaded capture? You might think you know the whole story but we dive deep into this mystery and uncover some interesting facts and theories.

In this week's episode, Tina tells the story of Angela and James Craig. Angela Pray Craig, 43, was an active, vibrant wife and mother to six children in Aurora, Colorado. Her husband, James, was a dentist with a busy practice. In March 2023, Angela was hospitalized 3 times. Doctors didn’t know what was causing her severe headaches, low blood pressure and disorientation. James had previously drugged Angela but insisted that he had not drugged her this time. Aa Angela’s health rapidly declined, an...

With her husband Frank out of town on business, 53 year old Nancy Howard was arriving home after picking up some takeout when she was accosted in her garage. The assailant took Nancy’s purse and shot her in the head. Was it a burglary gone wrong, or something more? Tune in for one of our craziest stories yet as we unravel the tale of Nancy and Frank Howard.

Pat Kimmi was a beloved mother of 4 and grandmother to 12 who went missing in November, 2009. She had recently divorced her abusive husband after 38 years of marriage. Her disappearance devastated her family and community who searched for her for weeks. They found clues along way, but it would take months for her body to be found. Who could have murdered this sweet lady? Was her husband involved? The answer might surprise you.

Rick Roehl and his wife April seemed to have it all - money, a perfect family, and a beautiful home. Rick was handsome and charming, while people said that April would light up a room. When April vanished without a trace, Rick claimed he would never hurt her, and that he would never give up trying to find her. Police were not fooled however. Tune in for our most shocking and tragic episode so far!

Larry McNabney was a successful, well-known lawyer, who seemingly vanished from the face of the earth on September 11th, 2001. Rumors began to swirl about Larry's wife Elisa and her young assistant Sarah Dutra, but it would take months for the mystery of Larry's disappearance to unravel. In part two of this two-part episode, we discuss the investigation into Larry's whereabouts and reveal what really happened to Larry McNabney.

Larry McNabney was a successful, well-known lawyer, who seemingly vanished from the face of the earth on September 11th, 2001. Rumors began to swirl about Larry's wife Elisa and her young assistant Sarah Dutra, but it would take months for the mystery of Larry's disappearance to unravel. In part one of this two-part episode, we discuss Larry's background and the circumstances around his disappearance.

Shanquella Robinson, 25, went to Cabo, Mexico with friends for a luxurious getaway in October, 2022. She did not survive the weekend. There were conflicting reports about what caused her death but a shocking cell phone video revealed that Shanquella suffered a brutal beating by one of the women she considered a friend. Shanquella’s friends and family are still waiting for justice to be served. This story will leave you shocked and heartbroken. #justiceforshanquellarobinson

In this bonus episode, we cover two cases in the news. First, the recent death of Abby Choi, a 28 year old socialite and influencer who was killed and dismembered by her ex-husband and in-laws in a devastating instance of greed. Second, we discuss wealthy aristocrat Constance Marten and her boyfriend Mark Gordon, whose disappearance along with their newborn baby in early January sparked a massive search in the UK.

John Miles Sharpe of Mornington, Australia brutally murdered his pregnant wife and 15 month old daughter in 2004 using a speargun. He disposed of their bodies and lied to police about their whereabouts for months. How long did his lies hold up and how was he caught? Listen today to find out about the horrible murders of The Mornington Monster.

In this bonus episode we discuss our feelings on the Murdaugh trial and the many victims of Alex, and we answer some listener questions about the case. Many thanks to listeners who sent in questions!

In this episode we discuss a true crime classic, John Emil List. On November 9, 1971, John List murdered his wife, three children and his mother before he disappeared without a trace. He became one of the FBI’s most wanted men, evading capture for 18 years. In part 2/2, we talk about how John List became Bob Clark. He was able to change his name but not his quirky personality, which ultimately led to his capture. We also go down a D.B. Cooper rabbit hole and revel in some amazing detective work.

In this episode we discuss a true crime classic, John Emil List. On November 9, 1971, John List murdered his wife, three children and his mother before he disappeared without a trace. He became one of the FBI’s most wanted men and evaded capture for 18 years. In part one of this two-part episode, we talk about John’s upbringing in Michigan, the early years of his married life and how things began to fall apart after the Lists purchased the mansion known as Breeze Knoll in Westfield, New Jersey.

Valentine’s Day is traditionally a day for flowers, candy, and romance. But sadly for Susan Hamilton, Valentine’s Day of 2001 would be the day she was savagely beaten and killed. Her husband, Dr. John Hamilton, came back to their Oklahoma City home after performing two surgeries that morning to find her lying on the floor of the bathroom with blood everywhere. Who would have killed Susan, and why?

As 2009 drew to a close, 47 year old Shele Covlin had a lot going for her. Her career was going well, she had two beautiful kids, and a family that loved her. Sadly, Shele did not live to see the New Year. Was her death a tragic accident or did her estranged husband Rod kill her? In part two of this two-part episode, we discuss the investigation into Shele's death, and Rod's appalling schemes to get at her money.

Debbie Collier was a 59 year old beloved mother who died under mysterious circumstances in September, 2022. Her last communication was a cryptic Venmo message to her daughter, Amanda, which led to much suspicion, speculation and confusion about her death. In this bonus episode, we discuss the circumstances around Debbie's mysterious death and whether it was suicide or foul play.